The Best Eyeliner Trick for Women Over 50, According to a Makeup Pro

If your eyeliner tends to smudge or disappear—or you’ve stopped wearing it altogether—this might be the makeup advice that transforms your routine.

As we age, features like the eyes can benefit from a little extra definition. But for many women over 50, applying eyeliner becomes trickier due to hooded lids, fine lines, or sensitivities. That’s why makeup experts recommend one essential update: keep lining your eyes—but do it smarter.

“A lot of women stop using eyeliner as they get older, but that can actually make the eyes appear smaller or more tired,” says makeup artist Laura Geller. Instead of skipping liner altogether, she recommends a refined approach to help lift and open the eyes—without harsh lines or smudges.

Choose a waterproof formula

If your eyeliner smudges or disappears halfway through the day, a waterproof pencil is key. Waterproof gel liners tend to stay put even on hooded or creased lids. “You want something long-wearing, so it doesn’t transfer to the upper lid,” Geller explains.

Stick to dark, flattering shades

Darker colours offer more contrast and definition, especially for mature eyes. Try classic shades like black, charcoal, or navy—soft enough to be wearable but bold enough to create impact.

Keep the line thin and tight

Thick eyeliner can make lids appear heavier. Instead, draw a slim line as close to the lash line as possible. “You’re not trying to create a dramatic wing,” Geller says. “The goal is subtle enhancement—just enough to define the shape of the eye.”

Look for eyeliner formulas that glide

Gel-based pencils tend to apply more smoothly and evenly, especially on delicate skin. A good eyeliner should feel weightless, not tug or pull, and stay in place all day.

The takeaway

Makeup routines can evolve with age—but that doesn’t mean skipping steps that add polish and confidence. A softly defined lash line can make a noticeable difference in how rested and radiant you look. With the right tools and techniques, eyeliner is still a staple worth keeping in your kit.