Exchanging gifts can feel like one of the more stressful parts of the holiday season for couples. When you give or receive something thoughtful, it can create a strong sense of connection—but there are just as many opportunities for tension and mixed emotions beneath all the wrapping paper.
We’ve all been there: one partner splurges on an engraved watch while the other hands over a simple card. Or, after months of hinting about a tennis racket, the big reveal ends up being a blender. These moments can leave you feeling overlooked or misunderstood.
The best way to avoid this? Have the conversation early. Talking about your gifting styles can save a lot of strife, especially if your approaches have clashed before or if it’s your first holiday together. Discuss expectations around budget, number of gifts and the kinds of presents you both value. Be upfront about what you can afford and what makes a gift meaningful to you. While surprises can be fun, they can also set up disappointment if your partner doesn’t read your cues. Remember, asking for what you want and receiving it can feel just as satisfying as an unexpected gesture.
If either of you is worried about the cost or effort of exchanging gifts, find ways to meet in the middle and get creative. Consider giving experiences or handmade items or even browsing a thrift shop together to pick out the quirkiest find. When you shift the focus from the “perfect” gift to the joy of connection, you open up countless ways to celebrate.
How to rethink the meaning of gifts
Instead of treating presents as a scorecard or a test of your relationship, consider stepping back and focusing on the intention behind them. Each of you may bring different strengths to the table—perhaps you’re a planner while your partner leans towards spontaneity. What matters most is the thought and care, not just what’s inside the wrapping paper.
It can also help to talk openly about the unspoken messages you both carry when it comes to gift-giving. Ask yourself: What kind of gifts feel most meaningful to me? Where did I learn that? Our family histories often shape the expectations we bring into relationships. If your family saved all year for one special holiday gift, a last-minute purchase might feel dismissive. If you grew up without big presents, receiving something small now might trigger disappointment, even if the value doesn’t matter as much as the gesture.
Pay attention to the stories you tell yourself about what a gift represents—whether it’s money spent, time invested or the thought that went into it. These narratives can colour how you feel about both giving and receiving. By sharing these perspectives with each other, you create space for understanding rather than silent assumptions.
In the end, if you notice any areas of disconnection, it’s far healthier to address them directly than to let gifts speak on your behalf. Clear, honest conversations help ensure that what’s exchanged—whether big, small, handmade or last-minute—feels rooted in care rather than miscommunication.
Create New Traditions Together
If gift-giving feels stressful or loaded with expectation, consider shifting the focus entirely by creating new traditions as a couple. This might mean planning a shared experience rather than exchanging physical presents. A picnic at the park, a weekend hike or cooking a meal together can feel just as memorable—if not more so—than anything that comes in a box.
Traditions don’t need to be extravagant to feel meaningful. You might decide to exchange handwritten notes each year, set a budget for quirky finds from local markets or even start a photo album that grows with each celebration. These small rituals build connection and can evolve alongside your relationship.
By reframing gifts as part of a larger ritual of care and togetherness, you remove pressure and allow joy to take centre stage. The real value lies not in what’s wrapped, but in the memories you’re creating together.
The Bottom Line
Gift-giving doesn’t have to be a source of stress or miscommunication in relationships. By being honest about your expectations, understanding each other’s stories around presents and creating new traditions, you can shift the focus from pressure to connection.
The most meaningful gifts are rarely the most expensive—they’re the ones that feel thoughtful and shared. When you and your partner approach the season with curiosity, kindness and a willingness to talk things through, you’re building something more lasting than what’s inside the wrapping paper: a deeper sense of trust and togetherness.
Newsletter
