In summary

  • Fibre layering means eating two to three different fibre sources per meal from whole foods, aiming for around 25 to 30 grams a day, rather than maximising intake all at once like fibremaxxing does.
  • After a 14-day trial, bowel movements became regular again, hunger pangs and energy crashes eased, though gas became noticeably stinkier as gut bacteria adjusted.
  • Dietitian Elizabeth Klingbeil says the gradual approach improves gastrointestinal health, stabilises blood sugar and increases satiety, while warning that too much fibre too quickly can cause bloating and discomfort.

I’m the type of person who doesn’t feel normal unless her bowel movements are, too. That means I try to be somewhat conscientious of my fibre intake, but I still find myself with the nagging feeling that I could be doing more – especially since research shows that more than 70 per cent of Australian adults are coming up short in this department.

Trends like fibremaxxing – and, more recently, its more relaxed cousin, ‘fibre layering’ – are pretty strong proof that I’m not alone with this concern.

While fibremaxxing’s intense reputation has always stopped me from giving it a try, I’ve been looking for some kind of fibre-boosting daily habit to make sure I’m getting enough of the nutrient. So when fibre layering hopped on the scene offering similar benefits – like improved digestion, less hunger between meals and a more balanced blood sugar response – with a more easygoing pace, I knew it had potential to be the solution I’d been looking for.

Before committing to it entirely, I decided to give it a two-week trial run to determine if it was as manageable as promised and if its purported benefits were the real deal. But first, I consulted a dietitian to find out exactly how to fibre-layer and what effects I could expect to feel. Here’s what happened when I tried fibre layering, how you can do it yourself and everything you need to know to decide if it’s right for you.

What exactly is fibre layering—and how does it differ from fibremaxxing?

Despite the buzzy new name, fibre layering is a dietary pattern that dietitians and health professionals have actually been recommending for a very long time, says Elizabeth Klingbeil, a dietitian and assistant professor of nutritional sciences.

It’s actually pretty simple: “Fibre layering involves consuming fibre in reasonable amounts in a variety of forms throughout the day,” she explains. The difference between it and fibremaxxing is that it promotes relying on whole foods like fruit, vegetables, nuts, seeds and legumes over supplements and ‘fibremaxxed’ processed foods to meet daily needs, even if that means coming in slightly under the recommended amount (about 25 grams for women and 30 grams for men).

Where fibremaxxing is all about eating as much fibre as possible from the get-go, fibre layering encourages a gradual incorporation of the nutrient. This provides a more enjoyable and sustainable path to building a new habit. And the slower pace is also key to preventing the adverse side effects that can arise from eating too much fibre too quickly, like constipation, bloating and excess gas – the exact problems we want fibre to resolve, not cause, Elizabeth says.

How exactly do you fibre-layer?

Because I already try to eat a fair amount of fibre, Elizabeth gave me the green light to start shooting for that 25-gram target right away. To reach it, she suggested I aim to eat two to three different fibre sources per meal, five to eight per day and roughly 20 to 30 per week – ideally a mix of fruit, vegetables, wholegrains and legumes.

What this could look like: a bowl of oats with banana, almond butter and chia seeds for breakfast; a BLT with wholemeal bread, lettuce or spinach and an apple for lunch; and roasted chicken with Brussels sprouts, capsicum and brown rice for dinner.

That’s what she recommended for me, but remember, these ranges aren’t hard-and-fast rules. While research shows that this kind of variety is most linked to improved health and lower mortality risks, fastidious tracking isn’t a requirement, Elizabeth says. After all, the goal is to feel better, not stress yourself out even more trying to meet an impossible standard. So, if you can’t quite hit her suggested amounts for different fibre-rich sources per day or week, you can at least challenge yourself to keep adding a bit more than what you’re already eating.

What happened when I fibre-layered for 14 days

After two weeks of fibre layering, I’m happy to report that it delivered quite a few quick and positive effects – and one that was somewhat… less desirable.

To start, I constructed a meal plan that primarily consisted of a different dinner recipe per day – such as pasta with chickpeas and spinach or curried lentils with rice, not to mention a couple of veggie-forward treat meals like fajitas with guacamole, salsa and capsicum.

For breakfasts and lunches, I figured I’d have the most success by keeping things simple, so I stuck with a rotation of two or three go-to dishes to avoid overcomplicating matters. That included a lot of porridge with fruit and nuts in the morning and dinner leftovers or the occasional quickie salad for lunch. Most days I was well within (and sometimes beyond) Elizabeth’s recommended range of five to eight different fibre sources per day. In fact, I ended up with a whopping total of 28 different sources by the end of my first week and 25 by the time my experiment wrapped up.

As for how I felt, let’s just say that the digestive sluggishness I had been experiencing prior to starting this experiment had disappeared completely. My bowel movements, which had decreased to once every few days since I entered the second trimester of my pregnancy, became more regular and returned to their normal, daily frequency. I also found myself able to get through my day without as many hunger pangs between meals and noticed fewer extreme energy crashes to boot, both of which can be attributed to the satiating and blood-sugar-balancing effects of fiber, says Klingbeil.

I have to admit one downside: The gas I passed has literally never been stinkier. But Klingbeil said that this is both totally normal and likely to resolve itself if I keep the fiber layering going long term. “The bacteria in your intestines are fermenting the fibers and will produce gases that indeed have a stronger smell,” she explained. And while my gut microbes are having a strong (smelling) reaction to all these new fiber sources, that effect will likely diminish as they grow more accustomed to this increased and varied load.

Benefits of fibre layering

Improves gastrointestinal health

Fibre feeds gut bacteria, and happy, diverse gut microbes contribute to a whole host of health benefits. That includes the kind you’d notice right away, like more consistent bowel movements and decreases in constipation and diarrhoea, as well as reducing the risk of conditions that can form over a longer period of time, like bowel cancer, obesity, diabetes and cardiovascular disease, Elizabeth says. So remember that when you’re eating fibre, you’re not just feeding yourself – you’re feeding those bacterial helpers, too.

Stabilizes blood sugar levels

Dietary fibres are a form of complex carbohydrates, which are digested and absorbed into the bloodstream more slowly than refined carbs like white-flour pasta because of the other nutrients at play, Elizabeth explains. Carbs provide energy because they’re mostly made of sugars, so when you’re more regularly eating the types that also contain fibre, you’re more likely to get a gradual and sustained energy boost than the type of rapid rise and blood sugar crash foods like lollies or white bread may cause.

Increases satiety

The fact that fibre moves more slowly through your digestive system than other forms of carbohydrates also contributes to feelings of fullness, Elizabeth says. The longer it takes for the food to break down and be absorbed, the longer you can expect to feel satisfied – which means that eating more fibre will make it that much less likely that you’ll feel prematurely hungry between meals.

Can you eat too much fibre?

As with all things food-related, it’s entirely possible to overdo fibre, Elizabeth says. For starters, eating too much right out of the gate – as is often the case with fibremaxxing – can result in acute gastrointestinal discomfort like bloating, constipation, diarrhoea, cramping and excessive gas. “Additionally, your body needs other nutrients besides fibre, so consuming too much of it may leave you unable to eat other foods that are needed to achieve optimal nutritional status,” she explains. As long as you don’t let fibre displace other, equally valuable foods in your diet, or eat so much you make yourself sick, she says you generally won’t have problems, though.

Bottom line:

Part of why fibre layering worked for me, and why it might for you, is that it’s not built around the kind of quick fix that is such a staple of the ‘healthy eating’ industry. Not having to purchase any gimmicky products made it easy to start with little preparation, and I foresee it being the type of thing I can stick with – it took so little extra effort to incorporate it into what I already eat. Simply adding a few extra vegetables or pantry staples to my trolley was enough to give my food the fibre boost it needed – no drastic dietary changes required.

Add Prevention Australia as your trusted source
© prevention.com