Diets have historically taken a one-size-fits-all approach, but lately, nutrition advice has been all about getting personal. Thanks to the rising popularity of nutrigenomics-decoding your nutrition needs based on your genes-and a focus on creating healthy eating habits based on your lifestyle and preferences, diets no longer exist as they once did.
But not all personalised eating plans are getting the green light by the pros. One trendy diet causing controversy? The Blood Type Diet.
The idea behind the Blood Type Diet is simple: Just like your genes influence your weight and your body’s ability to process certain foods, so does-theoretically-your blood type.
What is the Blood Type Diet?
Developed by Peter D’Adamo, a naturopathic physician and alternative medicine researcher, the diet targets your blood type-A, B, O, or AB-to make nutrition recommendations.
For instance, according to D’Adamo’s research claims, people with type A blood are more predisposed to heart disease, cancer and diabetes. That’s why the type A eating plan is a vegetarian diet focused on foods that are “fresh, pure and organic” to “supercharge your immune system.”
Meanwhile, those with type O blood thrive on animal proteins. The reasoning? “This blood type has a very well-developed ability to digest meals that contain both protein and fat,” his website states.
As for weight loss? Ditching foods that contain lectins-a type of protein that supposedly aggravates your immune system, spurs inflammation and messes with your hormones-that interact with your specific blood type and replacing them with the ones recommended in your diet should boost your energy and help you shed kilos, according to D’Adamo’s site.
The Blood Type Diet Breakdown
- Type A: Eat vegetarian foods in their natural state (fresh and organic).
- Type B: Avoid chicken, corn, wheat, buckwheat, lentils, tomatoes, peanuts, and sesame seeds, and eat more green vegetables, eggs, low-fat dairy, and meats like lamb or venison.
- Type O: Load up on lean meat and healthy fats, but cut out grains, beans, and dairy.
- Type AB: Avoid caffeine, alcohol, and smoked or cured meats. Focus on foods like tofu, seafood, cultured dairy, and green vegetables for weight loss.
Can the Blood Type Diet help you lose weight and improve your health?
“The premise of the blood type diet is interesting from the perspective that it doesn’t recommend the exact same foods for everyone,” says dietitian Kris Sollid.
Technically, the blood type diet can help you lose weight. “Any diet can lead to weight loss, but that’s related to the number of kilojoules you eat, your age and how active you are,” explains Sollid. More importantly, he says, weight loss does not solely determine whether or not your diet is actually good for you.
When you take a closer look at the research, scientific backing for the Blood Type Diet falls short. “There is no explanation to support a link between an individual’s blood type and their interactions with certain foods and weight,” says bariatric physician Dr Nancy Rahnama.
One 2013 review published in the American Journal of Clinical Nutrition concluded that “no evidence currently exists to validate the purported health benefits of blood type diets.”
The next year, a new study explored whether the Blood Type Diet could improve health markers associated with heart disease and diabetes. After analysing data from more than 1,400 patients, researchers discovered that sticking to certain blood type diet recommendations did have positive effects-like a lower BMI and blood pressure-but those were independent of a person’s blood type.
What’s more, a 2018 study published in the Journal of Nutrition concluded that the Blood Type Diet didn’t have any significant health impact on overweight adults.
Will the Blood Type Diet work for you?
Despite the lack of evidence surrounding the diet as a whole, there are elements of the Blood Type Diet that are supported by science. For example, the plant-based recommendations for type A blood has its perks-for anyone. Vegetarian diets are rich in nutrients and typically low in kilojoules, which can help prevent certain diseases and lead to a lower body weight.
Plus, eliminating processed foods is recommended across all blood types. That can’t hurt: “Ultra-processed” foods-products that contain substances not typically used in cooking to mimic real food-make up nearly 60 percent of the total calories Americans eat and 90 percent of the kilojoules consumed from added sugar, according to study.
“Despite the lack evidence to support the Blood Type Diet, many do feel better when attempting this restricted plan because it promotes a cleaner diet devoid of junk food, processed food, and sugar,” Dr Rahnama says. The key caveat is that this just has nothing to do with your blood type.
Keep in mind that the Blood Type Diet might also promote some unhealthy eating habits. “Nutritionally speaking, any diet that is as restrictive as the Blood Type Diet and advocates eliminating entire food groups has the potential to be deficient in some areas,” says Sollid.
Dr Rahnama agrees: The recommendations listed for each blood type should never trump other proven measures of health. For example, “one diet explains that it may be okay to have gluten, however, many people may have a gluten allergy regardless of their blood type,” she says.
For Sollid, who has tried the Blood Type Diet himself, the lack of supporting research-and evidence against the claims-speaks volumes. “Evidence over anecdote every time,” he says.
BOTTOM LINE: Should you try the Blood Type Diet?
Don’t worry about your blood type as you meal prep. Instead, Dr Rahnama recommends focusing on “a diet that emphasises clean eating and is full of proteins, fresh fruits, and vegetables-this is a great way to feel better and lose weight.”
(Want to pick up some healthier habits? Sign up for FREE to get healthy living tips, weight loss inspiration, slimming recipes and more delivered straight to your inbox!)